基于改良DOPS的形成性评价在心血管临床技能课程实训教学中的应用效果

    Application effect of formative assessment based on improved DOPS in practical teaching of cardiovascular clinical skills course

    • 摘要:
      目的 探讨以改良的临床操作技能直接观察评估(DOPS)作为形成性评价工具,在专业型硕士研究生心血管临床技能课程实训教学中的应用效果。
      方法 以空军军医大学2019级与2020级临床医学专业型硕士研究生为研究对象,分为对照组(113人)和试验组(115人)。对照组实施传统实训教学,试验组学生采用改良DOPS作为形成性评价在实训教学中实施并反馈。通过考核成绩比较和问卷调查结果分析评估改良DOPS的应用效果。
      结果 在DOPS单项考核指标中“寻求帮助技巧能力”项得分最低,且评价等级为“低于基本标准”,其中“适应证掌握”、“技能操作完成能力”两项得分最高;在考核成绩方面,试验组学生考核成绩((92 ± 6))分均明显高于对照组(81 ± 5)分,且有统计学意义(P<0.05);问卷调查结果显示,试验组学生在提高自主学习能力、临床思维能力、实践操作能力、职业素养自评、沟通协作能力等方面的自评得分均高于对照组(P<0.05)。
      结论 应用改良DOPS的形成性评价有利于提升专业型硕士研究生的心血管临床操作技能水平和学习能力,提高实训教学质量,值得广泛推广应用。

       

      Abstract:
      AIM To explore the effect of direct observation of improved clinical operation skills (DOPS) as a formative assessment tool in the practical teaching of cardiovascular clinical skills courses for professional master’s degree postgraduates.
      METHODS The subjects included in this study were Grade 2019 and Grade 2020 professional master’s degree postgraduates majoring in clinical medicine in Air Force Medical University, who were divided into a control group (113 subjects) and an experimental group (115 subjects). The control group received traditional practical teaching. For the experimental group of students, we adopted improved DOPS as a formative assessment and feedbacks were collected. The application effect of the improved DOPS was evaluated by comparing the examination results and analyzing the results of the questionnaire survey.
      RESULTS Among the single assessment indexes of DOPS, the score of "help-seeking skill ability" was the lowest and the evaluation grade was "lower than the basic standard". The scores of "indication mastery" and "skill operation completion ability" were the highest. In terms of test scores, the test scores of the experimental group (92 ± 6 points) were significantly higher than those of the control group (81 ± 5 points) (P<0.05). The results of questionnaire survey showed that the self-rating scores of the experimental group were higher than those of the control group in improving self-learning ability, clinical thinking ability, practical operation ability, professional quality self-rating, and communication and cooperation ability (P<0.05).
      CONCLUSION The application of modified DOPS is beneficial to improve cardiovascular clinical operation skills and learning ability of professional master’s degree postgraduates, as well as the quality of practical teaching, and it is worthy of widespread application.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回